90 Day Fiancé: Josh Weinstein Finally Reveals His Secret Girlfriend

90 Day: The Last Resort star Josh Weinstein is indeed in a relationship with a cast member whom he finally reveals soon amid his cheating scandal, and Natalie Mordovtseva fears her deportation. Natalie and Josh began their reality TV journey on The Single Life season 2. Natalie was still married to Mike Youngquist, and that’s why Josh refused to call her his girlfriend. However, the pair were together for almost three years. Every time they broke up, Natalie called Josh back to her, even though she knew Josh didn’t want a wife or a third baby mama.

ExtraTV shared a clip from the upcoming 90 Day: The Last Resort season 2 Tell All Part 4, revealing that fans were right and Josh is with Elizabeth Potthast’s sister, Jenn Potthast. The clip shows Shawn Robinson asking Jenn how long she has known Josh for. She reveals, “I don’t know maybe like seven years.” She reveals that they have a “history” wherein Josh knows her mother and her sisters. “Elizabeth and Rebecca used to work for me,” Josh adds. Jenn explained that Josh and she recently reconnected.

What Natalie’s Unexpected Message To Josh’s New Girlfriend Means

Natalie’s Reaction Is So Shocking!

Josh and Jenn had been seeing each other for a couple of months when they filmed the 90 Day: The Last Resort Tell All in January 2025. Josh refused to talk about whether he had slept with Jenn despite a lot of prodding by cast members such as Julia Trubkina. He eventually says “maybe” before revealing that they’re just having fun. Josh and Jenn had been on a couple of trips already, and they were planning another one in a month or two. Natalie has a sour look on her face when Josh and Jenn’s relationship is discussed.

However, when asked if she has a message for them, Natalie calls Jenn “beautiful” and tells her that she is happy for her. She hopes that everything works out well for them. Natalie doesn’t think that Josh will treat Jenn the same way he treated her. Cast members were surprised by Natalie’s reaction, since she wasn’t happy with Josh giving a different woman attention over her. Natalie’s response suggests she’s matured since filming the show and might have moved on herself.

Our Take On Josh Announcing Libby’s Sister Jenn As His New Girlfriend

Will Jenn Survive The Relationship?

Natalie wishes that Josh were a better partner to Jenn than he was to her. It’s not known if Natalie said it sarcastically, but Josh and Jenn have known each other for almost a decade and are family friends. There’s no chance that Josh will demean Jenn or lie to her or make false promises like he did with Natalie. Natalie had her reasons for tolerating Josh’s behavior. She was in a financial mess and needed his help from time to time. However, it’s not the case with the 90 Day: The Last Resort star and Jenn.